November 1, 2001
|

Sheryl Lee and David Wilson
next to one of the electrostatic panels from
the Wilson Audio WAMM system
|
Wilson Audio Specialties Factory Tour
by Marc Mickelson
Begun as an audiophile recording label, Wilson
Audio Specialties migrated into making speakers because of
founder David Wilson's innate interest in designing audio products.
His very first, the SM.AR.T turntable, debuted in 1973, but
the transition from recordings to speakers was not a direct
one. David Wilson was an audio journalist and recording engineer
who made his first speakers, the original WAMM and WATT, as
monitoring tools. Audiophiles heard of them, then heard them,
and the road to the current Wilson Audio was paved.
The area in the Wilson Audio factory that houses
the company's collection of artifacts from its history and
its table of awards is adjacent to a listening area that features
WATT/Puppy 6 speakers, Wilson Audio's best-selling product
and the current SoundStage! Network Edge of the Art award winner.
It's hard to overlook the connection between the past and present
in this room, but beyond it, Wilson Audio proved to be a thoroughly
forward-looking company that seemingly never rests or loses
sight of its goal: making only the best loudspeakers it can.
"But why are your speakers so expensive?"
Wilson Audio speakers are luxury products, and
not just because of their cost. Their finish is impeccable,
as is the company's support of its customers. This diamond-studded
reputation also makes Wilson Audio speakers the brunt of ridicule
from audiophiles who think they cost too much. After all, you
can buy speakers that are cheaper, even much cheaper, and people
seem to be happy with these too. But what consumers don't know
about are the careful manufacturing practices and advanced
materials that go into Wilson Audio products -- the things
obscured by the glossy finish.
The main criticism of Wilson Audio products is
the "It's just an MDF box" argument. Wilson speakers are made
from three different materials, and MDF is not one of
them. M material looks like MDF, but when you run your hand
over it, you'll quickly know it's not. M material is harder,
more dense and less resonant than MDF. It also costs eight
times what MDF does. The black X material was first used in
the Grand SLAMM and costs 16 times what MDF does. It's used
in the front baffles and bottom plates of various models as
well as wherever two surfaces meet, like with the WATT sitting
on top of the Puppy. X material requires no threaded inserts
when drivers or spikes are affixed to it because it's harder
than steel -- harder to mill too. Finally, WATT material is
white and more like ceramic than any kind of wood. It actually
cracks when stressed beyond its very high strength. Wilson
Audio uses it for the WATT as well as in the head piece of
the X-1 Grand SLAMM.
Wilson Audio has found that no one material is
ideal for all uses, so a major part of the design process is
determining which material to use for each element of a speaker.
This requires a great deal of experimentation and the construction
of mock-ups of the speakers with combinations of the various
materials.
|

Wilson Audio's listening area
at the factory.
|

The table of awards, including
two from Soundstage!
|
|

David Wilson's first audio
product, the SM.AR.T turntable.
|

WATT cabinets made of -- what
else? -- WATT material.
|
|

The Sophia cabinet uses both
X and M material.
|

The head units for a pair
of MAXX speakers in gun-metal blue. The picture
doesn't capture the unique hue of this finish.
|
The next knock against Wilson Audio speakers
is the "I can buy the same drivers off the shelf" contention.
While it's true that Wilson sources its drivers from manufacturers
like Dynaudio, ScanSpeak and Focal, most of the drivers are
designed by Wilson Audio and manufactured to their specifications.
This arrangement includes a three-year moratorium on the sale
of the drivers to anybody other than Wilson Audio. But what
about after the three years are up? You can then buy the same drivers
used in Wilson Audio speakers, right? Well, not exactly. Each
driver is substantially modified at the factory. Why is this
done? Because it's the only way Wilson Audio can get exactly
the performance they want from the drivers. I doubt the driver
manufacturers would undertake such hand work anyway -- their
business is mass producing drivers.
|

The WATT/Puppy 6 crossover module.
|
DIYers in particular like to think "There's nothing
special about the crossover." Each crossover for a Wilson Audio
speaker is potted in a Zero Halliburton aluminum case, which
provides some damping and hides the crossover elements. The
crossovers are "of various slopes, depending on the application," and
this is the extent of the information that Wilson Audio would
convey. They wouldn't even let me see the areas in which the
crossovers are designed or built. Yes, they definitely have
something to hide.
Finally, the finish of Wilson speakers is universally
praised, but "Do you want to pay all that money for a nice
paint job?" First, there are a few steps that take place before
painting to make the speakers look so crisp and attractive.
The cabinets are gel-coated and then hand sanded prior to painting,
which itself is a 12-step process. Wilson Audio will mix custom
colors too, often at no charge to their customers. The day
of my visit, a peach-colored WATCH Dog subwoofer was making
its way through the factory. Even the standard WilsonGloss
color palette is stunning, especially the relatively new gun-metal
blue that I saw on a pair of MAXXes. Note to the owner: you
have the best-looking speakers I've ever seen.
Manufacturing
A Wilson speaker begins life as sheets of the
various materials that are cut out on the company's four-head
CNC router. The materials used are very hard, and this takes
a toll on the CNC's cutting blades, which wear out quickly.
The pieces of the cabinet are joined with advanced adhesives
(another area that Wilson Audio has researched extensively),
and then the cabinet is cured for seven days, part of which
is spent in a large oven. Once the cabinet is properly cured,
the bonded joints are said to be stronger than the materials
themselves. There are no fasteners used in Wilson Audio speaker
cabinets.
|

MAXX cabinets (left) along
with Grand SLAMM cabinets. Notice the strategic
use of M, X and WATT materials.
|

The WATCH Dog subwoofer's
front baffle is made entirely of X material.
|

A pair of X-1 Grand SLAMMs
crated and ready for shipping.
|
While the cabinet is being built, the crossover
is also under construction and the drivers are burned in. Wilson
has accelerated the process of burning in the drivers by hitting
them with a series of tones for 12 hours, which equals a week
of heavy playing. Wilson also measures the drivers so precisely
that if one in a pair of speakers blows, they don't have to
send you a pair of drivers to replace. You will receive an
exact match to the blown driver.
After the cabinet has cured, its surface is gel-coated,
which produces a cabinet with a seamless appearance. It is
this fiberglass outer shell to which the paint will adhere.
The gel coat also has to cure, after which it is sanded to
remove any abnormalities and meet Wilson Audio's tolerances
for their cabinets.
Next comes the painting, followed by more curing,
after which the finish is buffed, inspected and buffed some
more if required. Customers can still order custom wood-veneer
finishes at additional cost, but such orders are rare nowadays.
Wilson Audio's visual standards are higher than those in the
automotive industry, and the rationale for this made sense
to me: cars move and speakers don't, so it's much easier to
see any imperfections on speakers. Near the end of my tour,
I was shown a few rejected cabinets, and the blemishes were
far more slight than you will see on finished products from
other manufacturers. But a blemish is a blemish, and Wilson
Audio doesn't tolerate them -- or pass them on to customers.
If the blemish can't be sanded or buffed out, the cabinet is
repainted completely -- or scrapped.
Once the cabinet has passed all inspection, it
is frisked -- covered with a cellophane-like film for transit.
Some buyers may be tempted to leave this film on their speakers
indefinitely, but they shouldn't as it doesn't allow the finish
to cure completely and will ruin the paint if not removed.
|

The shop.
|

Wilson Audio's four-head CNC
router.
|
|

The sanding area. Air-handling
machines suck dust out "so it doesn't contaminate
surfaces."
|

Inside the paint booth.
|
|

Putting the frisk on a Sophia.
|

Everything you need for a
pair of X-1 Grand SLAMM midrange modules.
|
The next step is for the cabinet to become a
loudspeaker. The drivers are affixed, the crossover wired in,
and the binding posts added. In the assembly area are exploded
drawings of each speaker model, and the sheer number of parts
that go into each is staggering. I'm sure these drawings would
be prized by DIYers, but they also serve as a reminder that
you just can't build a Wilson speaker at home.
The completed speakers are tested, and their
measurements are plotted against those of control speakers
of each model. If the measurements don't match, the problems
are rooted out and corrected. Wilson Audio keeps paperwork
on every speaker they've made, so if you need a driver at some
point, you'll only have to supply a serial number to get a
perfectly matched replacement.
After testing, the speakers are visually inspected
again. They are then packed in foam-lined wooden crates for
shipping. A pair of WATT/Puppy 6es weighs over 400 pounds in
their four crates, but that's nothing compared to the MAXX,
which weighs 1100 pounds in five crates, and the Grand SLAMM,
which tips the scales at almost a ton in seven crates. But
the product that's the greatest headache is the XS subwoofer
-- one 700-pound piece that itself is the size of a very large
shipping crate. Wilson Audio doesn't promote or advertise the
XS at all because of how unwieldy it is to build, pack, ship
and install. Yet, the company still sells a fair number of
them, to the great misfortune of the folks on the loading dock.
Listening
During my stay in Utah, I was able to hear two
Wilson speaker systems I'd never heard before, the MAXX and
WAMM. The MAXX resided in the living room of John Giolas, Wilson
Audio's marketing director, and was driven by Atma-Sphere MA-1
Mk II mono amps. Other equipment included an Aesthetix Callisto
tube preamp, Ayre V-1 CD/DVD player and Transparent Reference
XL cables.
John's living room is completely open to his
kitchen -- or perhaps it's the kitchen that's open to the living
room. The MAXXes dominate the space, which is roughly 16 feet
wide and 18 feet deep. The listening seat is 12 feet or so
from the speakers, which are over five feet tall. I was expecting
to feel like the guy in the Maxell ad -- blown backwards by
the force of the sound from such large speakers. But from the
first notes of Bob Dylan's "Don't Think Twice. It's All Right" to
the jazz and classical pieces John played, the big MAXXes simply
disappeared -- and it was startling. I'm used to bookshelf
monitors and thinner floorstanders being able to pull off this
trick, but never a speaker the size of the Wilson MAXX,
which floated images in a immense arc-shaped soundstage that
extended well beyond the speaker positions and walls. Tonality
was spot-on, and although the speakers taxed the Atma-Sphere
OTL amps down low, the bass had more than respectable oomph.
John attributed the disappearing act to the time and phase
alignment of the MAXX, which is adjustable in 39 increments.
No matter what the reason, this system was one of the very
best I've heard anywhere.
|

The equalizer for the WAMM
system. It begins life as a Crown professional
unit, which Wilson Audio modifies.
|
I was also treated to more music at David and
Sheryl Lee Wilson's home. A demonstration of the new Sophia
preceded listening to Wilson Audio's flagship, the $225,000
dynamic/electrostatic WAMM system, 53 of which are in existence.
The Wilsons' listening room is immense -- nearly 30'
x 40' -- and has a cathedral ceiling with absorbers built in
to further improve acoustics. On one end of the room is a Yamaha
grand piano, which was used as a reference for the Sophia demo,
and on the other the WAMM towers -- two for each channel --
driven by Mark Levinson No.33 amplifiers that are housed in
their own room with separate ventilation and 220V power lines.
Other equipment included an Audio Research preamp and Krell
CD player, and cables from Transparent. Equipment is one thing,
but the extent to which the Wilsons have gone to make a home for
their audio system is another -- and unprecedented in my experience.
|

The WAMM at home.
|
Describing the sound of the WAMM system in the
Wilsons' big room in the terms we reviewers use is fruitless
-- it exceeds all benchmarks by wide margins. Think you've
encountered a HUGE soundstage? You haven't. Think you've heard
scads of detail? You haven't. Think you've heard tremendous
bass depth, power, and slam? Erase that thought. The WAMM is
high-end audio on the very most exalted level. It melts away
walls, reveals all character of upstream equipment, conveys
the beauty of a recording and the nature of its venue, and
completely involves listeners in the music. Its sound in the
Wilsons' room is better than any reproduction I've heard regardless
of technology or software. A fitting end to the day was listening
to Guy Clark sing "Stuff that Works" on the WAMM system. Clark
was as large as life and standing, it seemed, on the balcony
outside the Wilsons' listening room. It worked for me.
It was a treat to listen to both the WAMM
and MAXX, but no more so than getting an inside look at how
Wilson Audio makes its speakers. High-end audio is about
pushing the envelope, but it seems clear that Wilson Audio
has its sights set beyond this -- to perfect the art and
science of making high-performance loudspeakers.
|