 |
| |
 |
| |
McIntosh MC1201 monoblock power amplifier
By Jonathan Scull, March 2001 |
 |
| |
While walking home from
the office the other day I passed a gleaming, perfectly detailed
Harley-Davidson, lightly customized, as many are these days.
I didn't stop and drool, but I couldn't unsnap my eyes from it.
As I drew parallel to that hawg, a Ricky Martin look-alike threw
his leg over the saddle and thumbed the starter. No, you don't
have to be a tattooed, beer-gutted redneck anymore to rear up
and slam down on a kick-starter of one of those beasts.
These days, it's all done with the push of a button. Dude.
Whirr...whirr...whirr...ka-BLAM! The bike didn't
so much start as explode into life. Though I wore
my best unimpressed New Yawker's face, I was keenly aware
of its sound as I ducked an errant cab and finished sauntering
across Sixth. The big twin settled quickly into its uniquely
throaty, lumpy idle, and I instinctively waited for Biker
Boy (lucky bastard) to give it the gas. Thonka-thonka-thonka
blat ka-BOOM chatter-chatter-thonka-thonka... I could
almost feel the vibration between my legs, the wind in my
hair. Hey, it was windy!
Would Biker Boy accelerate past me as he
blasted down 17th Street? Or turn up Sixth? The clutch took
up the slack, and The Great American Icon turned the corner
and roared up the Avenue of the Americas. Damn.
But I wasn't envious. I, too, had a Great
American Icon—a pair of them, in fact—waiting
for me in my listening room, warmed up and ready to rumble:
the McIntosh MC1201 solid-state monoblocks, 1200Wpc, with
the biggest power meters you ever saw this side-a Milwaukee.
Edifice rex
Like a Harley, each McIntosh MC1201 monoblock is a huge physical presence,
a big hunka iron in anyone's language: 147 gut-busting pounds of
stainless-steel chassis and beautifully finished, black-shrouded
transformers and heatsinks. Do yourself a big favor and
let your dealer install them. You're the one paying the
long booty—why should you have to schlep?
The MC1201's front panel is dominated by
a huge blue backlit Output Wattmeter under glass—plastic
could warp, according to McIntosh's Larry Fish. The ever-affable
Mr. Fish, VP of product planning (he worked his way up to
VP/chief engineer in his 27 years with the company) is quite
proud of the analog meters, which are handbuilt in the UK
and were originally designed for automobile test systems.
How apropos.
The meter is an audiophile big deal, as
explained rather elaborately in the Product Preview I received
from McIntosh. An amplifier's power output (in watts) is
determined by multiplying its output voltage (E) by its output
current (I): EI=W. However, the output meters on some amps
are actually voltmeters; output current is
not taken into consideration, the company patiently explains.
Even though these indicators may be calibrated in watts,
they're based on the "patently false notion" that all speakers
have a fixed impedance regardless of frequency.
For a specific output voltage, McIntosh
continues, the current varies inversely to the speaker's
impedance. If the impedance is lower, the output current
and power are higher. "Since McIntosh cannot control other
manufacturers' speakers, we decided to provide extra output
current to drive these mismatched low impedances and to indicate
the real output power required to drive them. Therefore
the meter circuit in the MC1201 electronically measures both
voltage and current, multiplies them, and displays the real
output power in watts."
The meter uses a circuit that accelerates
the pointer movement. When the pointer reaches its peak excursion, "it
pauses only long enough for the human eye to perceive its
position, then drops." Fish proudly asserted that the pointer's
operation is almost 10 times as fast as a professional VU
meter. Another feature of this stupendously large meter is
its ability to respond "95% full scale to a single-cycle
tone burst at 2kHz." What you see is what you get!
Although the meter's primary output calibration
is from 12mW to 1200W, there are smaller 2400W and 4800W
indicator positions to the far right! Impressive. "The MC1201
cannot reach this power level continuously; however, it is
possible for short-interval peaks to considerably exceed
the 1200W continuous rating." When I read this, I had a brief
vision of clamping the front brake, cracking the throttle,
and smokin' the rear tire! For the record, I never
got either amp anywhere near its indicated full-power
output when driving the sensitive (92dB) JMlab Utopia loudspeakers.
I think I nudged 120W during a particularly enthusiastic
listening session late one night, but more could not have
been asked.
Lower left on the front panel, a large
but easy-turning switch changes the meter to Watts, Watts
Hold, and Lights Off operation. In Watts Hold, the needle
locks to the highest power peak in any sequence, the reading
held until a higher peak passes. If no greater peak occurs,
the indicator slowly returns to its rest position at a decay
rate of 6dB/minute. In Lights Off mode, the meter functions
as normal, with the back-lighting turned off. (Don't worry—you
still get the cool, green McIntosh logos to light up your
listening room.)
The Power switch has three positions: Off,
Remote, and On. Off disconnects the main AC line, and Remote
is used when the amplifier is turned on by remote control.
(You'll need a connection between one of the Mac preamplifiers'
Power Control Out and the Power Control In on the rear of
the MC1201 to carry the 5V trigger signal.) The On position
bypasses the remote control and powers the beast up.
|
'Round back, just like the McIntosh MC2000
tube amp (which I reviewed last March), multiple "Autoformer" output
taps offer 2, 4, and 8 ohm connections on heavy WBT five-way
binding posts with multiple neutral taps so you don't have to
make your cables say "ahhh." There's not much clearance between
the back panel and the binding posts, so getting a grip on the
WBTs can be a little stressful for pudgy audiophile fingers and
bad Boomer knees. But the big WBTs, just as are found on the
rear of the JMlab Utopias, are large, beautifully made connectors
with integral locking mechanisms. Their use, bar the sonics for
a moment, are part of the McIntosh image. Mac Men at Work. I
suppose that "mystique" is part of what attracts the Japanese
collectors who so worship early McIntosh gear. The MC1201s carry
along in that same tradition—quite intentionally, and with
reason. Nothing wrong with classic design, after all.
Balanced connections are made at the switch-selectable
XLR input, which is rather individualistic in not using the
universal locking-type XLR connector that snaps the fitting
into place. I had no trouble with that, but it did catch
my attention. I think it's the small details that define
an audiophile design, and there lie the differences in most
stark relief. In my opinion. A pair of standard RCA connectors
are provided for unbalanced inputs.
The IEC mains-in connector is set horizontally
on the left rear of the chassis; some of the larger audiophile
power cords I used rose in wide, stiff arcs over the amps
before snaking their ways to the AC outlets.
The imposing faceplate is nicely set off
with a pair of what McIntosh describes as extruded aluminum
anodized handles in "champagne gold." They look like matte
silver to me, and are set off nicely against the big, shiny
chassis and the hulking black upper structure. Classic McIntosh.
The MC1201 costs $7500 each. (Larry
Fish was chuckling about a customer waiting to upgrade the
half-dozen MC1000s in his home-theater system with a sextet
of 1201s.) Of course, McIntosh makes speakers designed to
take full power from these huge amps. The loquacious Mr.
Fish then told me that their People's Republic of China dealer
had set up—on stage in a concert hall—a triamped
system with a pair of McIntosh XR290 loudspeakers powered
by six MC1000s, and sold tickets! He said it was a successful
event.
Design Philosophy
McIntosh's goal for the MC1201 was that its every stage of voltage
or current amplification would be as linear as possible. To accomplish
this, they used the following techniques.
First, "each transistor is selected to
have nearly constant current gain (Beta) over the entire
range of currents at which the transistor must operate." The
load impedance presented to each amplification stage is as
uniform as possible for all signal levels. The input impedance
of stages is increased and "linearized where possible by
using emitter degeneration." Resistors and capacitors in
the signal path are carefully selected to have "exceedingly
low voltage coefficients—low change of resistance or
reactance with applied voltage." Precision metal-film resistors
and low-dielectric-absorption film capacitors are used in
all critical circuit locations. Output transistors have matched
uniform current gain, "high-current gain-bandwidth product," low
output capacitance, and "a large active-region safe operating
area."
According to the documentation, "These
characteristics and the automatic-tracking bias system eliminate
crossover distortion. The distortion graphs supplied show
clearly that distortion does not increase at low power output
levels." Ah-ha—I'd wondered about that. According to
the estimable Mr. Fish, only the first watt or two is biased
into full class-A operation.
The MC1201 is fully balanced from input
to output. Two matched amplifiers operate in push-pull, with
their outputs combined at the Autoformer, so each half of
the amplifier contains complementary balanced circuitry.
McIntosh claims that the resulting "double balanced" configuration
cancels virtually all distortion, and that "this circuit
is possible only with the exclusive McIntosh Output
Autoformer," which provides matching for 2, 4, and 8 ohm
loads.
The output transformer coupling, or Balanced
Dual Core Autoformer in Mac Speak, is rarely seen with solid-state
designs, and provides "low-distortion power transfer and
delivers peak output current in excess of 200 amperes." The
MC1201 is said to have the output-current reserve to deliver
more than 5kW output on tonebursts. Of the Autoformer, McIntosh
says, "There is absolutely no performance limitation. Its
frequency response exceeds that of the output circuit itself,
and extends well beyond the audible range." The Autoformer
also protects speakers from damage in the event of amplifier
failure. Should a DC component appear in the output circuit,
it is shunted by the transformer and thus causes no damage
to the speaker.
As laid out by McIntosh, the basic circuit
is a time-honored one: two balanced stages of voltage amplification
followed by three stages of current amplification. All stages
are complementary balanced, as noted. This means, McIntosh
points out, that the amplifying stages have less total harmonic
distortion and that less negative feedback is required to
achieve "ultra-low" distortion.
|
How low can you go? "Output distortion is
so low," claims McIntosh, "it defies measurement, even with the
finest distortion analyzers. At mid-frequencies, 8 ohm load,
the distortion meter reads the residual distortion of the test
oscillator (0.0002%) with or without the MC1201 in the circuit.
This means the amplifier distortion is lower than the analyzer
is capable of measuring."
The signal is fed to the positive inputs
of the balanced differential stages. Feedback from the amplifier
outputs is applied to the inputs, and the differential amplifiers
drive a balanced Darlington-connected voltage amplifier stage.
The voltage amplifier's output feeds complementary Darlington
driver transistors. These supply the signal to 24 complementary
transistors per side for a total of 48 output transistors.
Ancillary components for features such as Power Guard, Sentry
Monitor, the meter, and protection circuits "interconnect
with the amplifier circuits."
The power supply uses a massive toroidal
transformer, full-wave bridge rectifiers, and large filter
capacitors with 600 joules of storage. The four large heatsinks
that bristle on the back of the chassis provide more than
2800 square inches of surface area with which to cool the
power-output devices.
Power Guard and Other Sentries
I think we can all agree that an amp driven into clipping, especially
a solid-state one, can sound harsh. Clipping, McIntosh explains,
looks and acts like the nonmusical squarewaves produced when an
amplifier is asked to put out more power than it's designed to
deliver.
"When an amplifier is driven into clipping,
it can deliver up to 40% harmonic and intermodulation distortion.
In this mode, the sound is grossly distorted and the extra
energy content of the clipped signal will damage most loudspeakers.
The McIntosh Power Guard circuit protects your ears and your
speakers from this kind of damage." This has been a public
service announcement...Power Guard is a McIntosh design (US
patent 4048573).
The Power Guard circuit is a comparator
that monitors the input and output waveforms. As McIntosh
explains it, normally there's no disparity between these
signals, so the circuit produces no output. When the MC1201
is overdriven and a difference develops, and if that difference
exceeds 0.3%, the comparator output turns on the amber Power
Guard indicator. If there's a further increase in distortion,
the output of the Power Guard circuit engages an attenuator
at the amplifier input. Reducing the amplifier gain
simply holds the amp's output to a low-distortion value.
However, Power Guard operates "only when the amplifier is
asked to deliver more power than it was designed to produce"—a
situation that I can't imagine. I never saw any amber
light go on, I can tell you that, and I played 'em loud! McIntosh
claims that the Power Guard acts so fast that there are "no
audible side effects and the sonic purity of the music reproduction
is perfectly preserved."
The Sentry Monitor joins the Power Guard
in protecting your investment. Per McIntosh, all power transistors
are limited in the maximum amount of power they can handle. "The
MC1201's output transistors and power supply have been designed
to allow very high current flow into properly matched load
impedances. If, however, a short circuit or very low value
of load impedance is applied to the output of the amplifier,
destructive current levels could be reached. The Sentry Monitor
circuit prevents this. The circuit senses the dynamic operating
time, voltage, and current of the amplifier output stage
and confines it to nondestructive levels. Sentry Monitor
does not limit the power output available from the amplifier."
Thermal Control over the output transistors
is also in the cards. The MC1201 uses an efficient output
stage biased into class-AB2. Larry Fish claims that while
the MC1201 runs pretty toasty, it produces relatively little
heat for the output power produced. Four large heatsinks
dissipate transistor-generated heat. "Natural convection
air flow is sufficient for cool operation. Should the cooling
air be blocked or should the amplifier operating temperature
become too high, thermal cutouts turn off the input signal
to the amplifier. When the amplifier has cooled, it will
automatically turn on again." Again, it never happened, and
I can't imagine provoking them to do so.
Turn-on inrush current is "cushioned" by
thermistors in the primary power transformer circuit; the
resultant soft start eliminates stress. There's also a turn-on
delay circuit that holds back amplification for about two
seconds after power is applied, to prevent pops or thumps
from insulting your loudspeakers.
|
Setup
It's funny—sometimes I can drop a component into the system and
reach almost immediate sonic harmony. Most of the time, the process is
more laborious. I keep three or four preamps around here, several amps
and digital front-ends, several families of cables, all of which I've
used over the past few years, and the sound of each is a familiar treat.
I have a good instinct for what'll work and what won't. In general,
I don't feed a high-output-impedance preamplifier (Balanced Audio Technology,
Conrad-Johnson) into low-impedance amplifier inputs (Linn, McIntosh).
When a component is fully differential-balanced, I run the whole system
that way, if possible. Don't assume; some components like running on
different phases of positive, others the same phase. I'm set up here
to do either quite easily.
Cardas Golden Reference interconnect and
Golden Cross speaker cable work fine with harsh-sounding
components as they break in, and continue to sound utterly sophisticated as
the sound improves. I try stuff powered from the Power Plant
and directly from the wall. It's usually a struggle to get
the device under test up on the bubble of best sound. When
I do, it's "Hold!" and "Let's take that shot!" I begin to
write the review, tweak a little more, then go back to my
familiar references to finish things out.
Like the Cary CAD-1610-SEs (reviewed in
December 2000), the MC1201s were a pain in the pancreas to
set up just right. First off, and most noticeable, they took
more than 100 hours to break in and open up, and 200 hours
had gone by before I really got into them. It was an uncomfortable
start—I thought I was staring a disaster in the face.
(No matter what some negative nogoodniks bleat, we always tell
it like it is at Stereophile.)
Best sound was achieved without a preamp,
feeding the McIntoshes from the analog outputs of the dCS
Elgar Plus on a dual-AES 24-bit/192kHz datastream, primed
by the dCS Purcell or the dCS 972 D/D converters via Synergistic
Research Designer's Reference interconnect, and Cardas or
XLO The Limited speaker cables. I had to turn the ASC Studio
Traps around to face more of their absorbent surfaces directly
toward the drivers than is typical around here. Otherwise,
the amps could still sound a little thin, electronic, and "hi-fi" on
top. I'd say this was the one sonic attribute I remained
aware of that I had to "fight" for best sound—that,
and a big, bloated, but powerful bass that finally firmed
up into audiophile-approved territory as the hours accumulated.
Run direct, get those Studio Traps just
right, and, bada-boom bada-bing, audiophile-approved super
sound. But remember: Without all this attention to
setup and matching, the MC1201s sounded a little acerbic
in the highs. Then again, you won't buy into the McIntosh
ethos and order up a pair of these $15k/pair monoblocks unless
you really want them. If you do, the implication is that
you'll set 'em up and match 'em properly, or at least have
it done for you.
Once the amps ran in and these elements
were accounted for fine-tuning the room treatments, I got
the sound described below.
Loitering with Intent
The MC1201s made a BIG sound in our loft. Everything about them, from
their hulking physical presence to their sound, was enjoyably larger
than life. In that way, they were similar to the tubed stereo McIntosh
MC2000, an amplifier I described as being a star of stage and screen
itself. But the MC1201s were more Harley-Davidson Macho, more massively
solid-state in how they went about making that positively huge
sound. In that way, they did draw attention to themselves.
I'm talking gobs of bass, effortless power
and dynamics on big, complicated transients throughout the
audible frequency band, and a huge, floaty, billowing soundstage
in and on which the musical narratives took place. I'm not
saying the MC1201 couldn't be subtle—for 15 big ones,
you have the right to demand detail and finesse, and you
get it. It's just that its priorities were different. To
me, the McIntosh aesthetic, build, and sound are more like
the two-page Cadillac ad that's been appearing in The
New Yorker—an on-track shot of Caddy's Le Mans
racer with a bumper sticker that reads "My other car is
an STS." That's it exactly. Think Offenhauser roadster
or Briggs Cunningham, Lance Reventlow and Scarab, Carroll
Shelby and Cobra, Henry Two (and his nemesis, Il Commendatore)
and the Ford GT40—proper American overweight
monsters built like Kelvinators!
So let's roll up our sleeves and break
out the welding torch, shall we? Reproducing classic recordings
is just what these amps are cut out to do, so let's begin
with a terrific new XRCD from JVC, Thelonious Himself (VICJ
60170), mastered in what engineer Akira Taguchi calls "big
mono." Most XRCD masterings are notable for their somewhat
soft and analog-like ambience. Nothing wrong with that, especially
given the MC1201's propensity to slightly brilliantize the
upper registers and make them a little glitzy, like a Harley.
I mean, how can you criticize it? But in the end it's unmistakable
and rather blatant, if you see what I mean.
In the event, with the Studio Traps turned
in just so, the sound was excellent via the dCS direct. Listening
to Monk that day seemed to define the audiophile experience
for me—enjoying the music, thinking about how to express
the sound and feeling, the meaning of a phrase, Monk's timing,
the very thoughtfulness that went into each musical expression.
The piano was, according to my notes, "very full-toned, with
excellent overall power response, again slightly tipped up
at the top, open if not completely without edge. But edge
in the sense of the true nature of a piano's strings, which
are, after all, made of metal." The soundstage, and the imaging
thereon, were so BIG that they carried a real sense of being
there into our listening room. Not subtle, but still very
enjoyable.
|
For instant sonic bliss, turn to track 5 of Modern
Jazz Quartet (EastWest Japan AMCY1165). That's Jerome Kern's "Yesterdays," followed
immediately by "Bags' Groove," another on my all-time hit parade.
As Bags beat his vibes, I tapped: "It's thrilling to get this
close to the music, to cozy up and feel without effort the 'vision'
of the composer or performer playing out before me. That's certainly
one of the privileges of being an audiophile, no? I think if
more people realized how effectively audiophiles escape
by 'levitating into the audiophile zone,' the High End would
succeed more widely. Perhaps that's why music and its reproduction
are so passionately pursued, and argued about ad infinitum. It's
an addiction, and everyone's passionate about their addictions."
The stereo MJQ recording was cushy and
illuminated, Milt's vibes fast and brilliant. The sound was
more transparent than I'd experienced with the MC1201s before,
so I had another look at the fold-out insert. It was mostly
in Japanese, but when I scanned the bit of English printed
there, you coulda knocked me over with a feather—it
was an old Atlantic remastered with 20-bit K2 processing!
I couldn't find JVC's name or logo anywhere, but K2 is what
Yoshida and Taguchi have been churning out those great-sounding
XRCDs with. Realizing that, it struck me how much the two
recordings sounded alike, with their large, lushly painted
sonic landscapes for your acoustic third eye to feast on.
The tonal color and shimmer of the vibraphone once again
raised the hackles on my neck.
Enjoying MJQ—and perhaps DCC's
finest release, Bags Meets Wes! (GZS-1093), with Milt
Jackson and Wes Montgomery—I took some notes. "Nice
image padding and placement, good, very round palpability,
and nice lush'n'shimmer in the lower treble as so ably struck
by Bags hisself in this sublime moment of proto-late-'50s
jazz, a template of sorts for all to come. Lush...lush...the
lazy circling of Connie Kay's wire brushes on his snare drums
rattling around like fine golden chips on a scrim of gossamer
sound." It was so immediate and vibrant it gave me the shivers.
While I'm no great fan of Chausson, do
yourself a favor and find Musique Français pour Clarinette & Piano (Lyrinx
LYR 2195, SACD/CD hybrid, distributed by Harmonia Mundi,
available through Acoustic Sounds), where you'll also find
works by Saint-Saëns, Debussy, Widor, and Poulenc. During
the Allegro animato of Saint-Saëns' Sonata Op.167,
I noted that "the clarinet has rarely sounded so vibrant
and alive, so burnished and acoustically buoyant. Like a
spring day, it gave my heart joy to feel the energy of such
beautiful playing on such a gorgeous-sounding CD layer. (John
Atkinson currently has the Accuphase DP-100/DC-101 SACD/CD
converter; I'll tell you more about the SACD layer when the
Accuphase returns, which will be soon. Right, John? John?)
Debussy's Rhapsody No.1 is utterly beautiful
music, wonderfully recorded, and alone worth the price of
the disc. Once again, I noted a distinct and natural sense
of atmosphere, an acoustic of involving proportions.
Interestingly, and no doubt due to miking techniques, the
clarinet sounded anything but pinpoint, while the piano reproduced
with the appropriate image size, nicely balanced with the
clarinet. In a very French way, the piano was a touch laid-back
in the soundstage, less prominent than might be the
case on another recording. The spotlight was always on the
clarinet, accentuated slightly by the MC1201s in their way,
yet the tonality and the elegiac, rhapsodic music has to
be heard this way to be appreciated.
The Poulenc clarinet sonata is a real treat;
I love it. It's adventurous, stunningly "intellectual," yet
as light on its feet as Pan. The MC1201s dug it all out and
delivered it whole, and it sounded very full. Don't
play the next track, Romance for clarinet and piano,
unless you're ready for some serious action from your spouse
or S/O. The piano's lower registers typified the Big Macs'
output: no overhang in the highs at all, a clean and
detailed midrange tilting toward the lush side, and a definitely big,
lush bottom end with heavy-hitting grunt, power, and sweep.
Not ready to let this disc go, I enjoyed
the effusive last movement of the Poulenc sonata, Allegro
con fuoco, in which clarinetist Florent H;aeau and pianist
Patrick Zygmanowski sound like young artistic stallions,
doing a zesty, wonderful job with the music. I could feel the
enthusiasm, the timing, the pleasure in the notes. Bravo.
Once again, I'd rediscovered the very purpose of the High
End. Get this disc.
To round things out, I then turned to the
innovative, floppy-limbed Moby and Play (V2 63881-27049-2).
I'm indebted to reader Dan Turner (danturner@computron.net),
who wrote to explain that the sound I'd picked up in the
background of several tracks on this great recording was
that of a film projector, "the sort we used to watch in biology
class in middle and high school that would melt the film
if it got stuck." I remember, Dan, all too well. I recall
filmstrips on hygiene, and how to "duck and cover"! (New
digital format! Everyone under the desks!)
The bottom end on track 4 of Play, "Why
Does My Heart Feel So Bad," was, according to my notes, "big,
powerful, and vast enough to sate all but the most jaded
and demanding listeners." The sheer quality and power of
the track's deep, abusive bass was massively impressive,
as was track 12's kick-drum sound. In absolute terms, it
sounded to me as if the MC1201s delivered ultra-power and
grip on the bottom, but not as deeply or as cleanly as the
Linn Klimax manages, if the Scots amp is a bit smaller in
scale. It's just that everything was so BIG on the Macs,
even and especially the bass. The deepest stygian depths
were perhaps a slight bit masked by all the exciting stuff
going on just above and up into the midrange.
Throughout Play, I heard that luscious,
billowy midrange, that huge signature soundstage, "over,
under, around, and through!" The JMlab Utopias seemed to
disappear, the recorded soundstage taking over the acoustics
of our listening area with no apparent effort whatsoever,
particularly via the Linn CD12/Mark Levinson Reference 2
combo with all Cardas cables. That, as George Cardas would
drawl, was special.
That film-projector sound at the beginning
of Moby's "The Sky is Broken" sets the stage, functioning
for me almost as an emotional dither that was very effective
and evocative. Lots of detail through the big Macs, especially
in the upper midrange. Moby's on top of the microphone—you
can hear him almost swallow the thing! I sensed him in a
very physical way wriggling around behind the microphone,
which he "plays" in the same way he does other instruments.
Anyway, digging Moby deep, I picked up
on the sweet, dreamy, somewhat plump lower midrange that,
while not the last word in resolution, was enjoyable and
entertainingly BIG. (What a surprise.) The midrange was cushy
too, with high frequencies fully in attendance, the lower
treble popping out at me as usual from the overall rather
laid-back presentation.
Darling, give me my pipe, my slippers,
and a beautiful woman...and you can have my pipe and slippers!—William
Powell as Nick Charles in Song of the Thin Man
The McIntosh MC1201s are hugely powerful
amplifiers whose true outer limits I never reached. The JMlab
Utopias are so efficient that if I played them any louder
than I did, I'd have blown my ears out. The Macs were like
big, burbling V8s. You can mosey a 427 'Vette around at 5mph
to leer at the babes, but a simple stab at the Loud pedal
will launch you immediately into HyperSpace, leaving
your hairpiece fluttering in the breeze. Or cruisin' on a
$60k "hawg" (hardly) from California Choppers and "blatting" the
proles with a run up the revs. Ah, life is good.
The MC1201 is not voluptuous like the MC2000, la
dolce vita of tube amps. Nope, these monsters are for
guys who'd rather get switched than have anything other
than McIntosh. Like my pal Dan Billet. If you're a successful
McIntosh kinda guy, you like a somewhat forward sound in
the highs, and you absolutely love big blue meters...what's
stoppin' you? If you're some kinda Liberal Democrat New
Yawkah like yrs trly and you're spoiled rotten more often
than not, well, you might pick a few nits—mostly
in that little tipped-up region in the lower midrange that
makes the MC1201 sound rather more "hi-fi" than I prefer
on some absolute scale of perfection. And the MC1201 is
perhaps not the last word in ultimate resolution.
But, as Kal Rubinson said some time ago
regarding another component, that's my problem. It might
not be yours.
|
Sidebar 1: Specifications
Description: Solid-state monoblock
power amplifier with output load impedance terminals for
8, 4, and 2 ohms. Output power: 1200W into 8, 4, or 2 ohms
(30.8dBW, 27.8dBW, 24.8dBW, respectively), minimum sinewave
continuous average power output rated 20Hz-20kHz. Output
RMS voltage: 98V across 8 ohms, 69.3V across 4 ohms, 49V
across 2 ohms. THD: 0.005% maximum from 250mW to rated power
output. Intermodulation distortion: SMPTE 0.005% maximum
if instantaneous peak power output does not exceed twice
the output power rating. Dynamic headroom: 2.1dB. Frequency
responses: 20Hz-20kHz, +0/-0.25dB; 10Hz-100kHz, +0/-3.0dB.
Input sensitivity: 2.45V unbalanced, 4.9V balanced. Signal/noise
ratio: 93dB, A-weighted, unbalanced (120dB below rated output),
97dB balanced (124dB below rated output). Damping factor:
8 ohm output, !w100. Input impedance: 10k ohms. Power Guard: <2%
THD with 14dB overdrive. Power requirements: 120V, 50/60Hz,
15A UL/CSA.
Dimensions: 17.75" (460mm) W by 11" (280mm) H by
19.625" (500mm) D. Weight: 147 lbs.
Serial numbers of units reviewed: SL1002/1003.
Price: $7500 each. Approximate number of dealers:
300.
Manufacturer: McIntosh Laboratory Inc., 2 Chambers
Street, Binghamton, NY 13903. Tel: (607) 723-3515. Fax: (607)
723-1917. Web: http://www.mcintoshlabs.com/.
|
Sidebar 2: Associated Equipment
Analog source: Forsell Air Force
One turntable, van den Hul Grasshopper Gold cartridge.
Digital source: Linn CD12, dCS 972 and Purcell D/D
converters, Elgar Plus D/A processor.
Preamplifiers: Balanced Audio Technology VK-50SE,
Mark Levinson No.32 Reference, Conrad-Johnson 16LS.
Power amplifiers: Krell FPB 350MC and Linn Klimax
Solo 500 monoblocks, Forsell Statement.
Loudspeakers: JMlab Utopia.
Cables: Digital: XLO The Limited, RCA and AES/EBU.
Interconnects: Cardas Golden Reference, TARA The One, Synergistic
Research Designer's Reference Discrete and Active Shielding.
Speaker: Cardas Golden Cross, TARA The One, XLO The Limited,
Synergistic Research Designer's Reference, Linn K400. AC:
PS Audio Lab Cable, Synergistic Designer's Reference Master
Couplers Squared, Coincident CST.
Accessories: ASC Studio Traps, Argent RoomLenses,
API Ultra Enhancers, PS Audio P300 Power Plant with Multiwave
upgrade, Signal Guard platforms, Black Diamond Racing shelves
and cones, DH Labs cones, Bright Star Air Mass and Big Rock
combo, PolyCrystal amp stand, equipment racks, cones, and
cable towers.—Jonathan Scull
|
Sidebar 3: Measurements
My usual practice is to subject amplifiers
to a one-hour preconditioning period at 1/3 power. In the
case of the humongous McIntosh MC1201, that meant 400W into
8 ohms from its 8 ohm output transformer tap. (One-third
power is chosen because this maximally thermally stresses
an amplifier with a class-B output stage.) To my surprise,
the MC1201 shut down after 40 minutes or so, its heatsinks
too hot to touch. This happened again during the testing.
Each time, the MC1201 could be reset once it had cooled down,
but this suggests that the amplifier is not recommended for
continuous operation at very high output levels. (The Grateful
Dead were supposed to have used powerful McIntosh amplifiers
for their sophisticated and high-quality "wall of sound" PA
system in the 1970s.)
The MC1201 was noninverting from both its
single-ended and balanced inputs (the XLR for the latter
is wired with pin 2 "hot"), while its input impedance at
1kHz was a low 8.6k ohms unbalanced, 17k ohms balanced. The
voltage gain into 8 ohms varied as expected, according to
which output transformer tap and input were used. The single-ended
figures were 32.1dB, 28.1dB, and 25.9dB into 8, 4, and 2
ohms, respectively. The balanced figures were all 6dB lower,
which will be on the low side for some preamplifiers.
The output impedance also varied according
to the output tap used, and proved difficult to accurately
assess due to the output voltage's tendency to drift a bit
in the unloaded condition. But as best I could tell, the
midband impedance was 0.28 ohm, 0.2 ohm, and 0.175 ohm from
the 8, 4, and 2 ohm outputs, respectively, rising a little
at 20kHz. This is pretty good for an amplifier using an output
transformer. As a result, the modification of the MC1201's
response due to interaction with the manner in which the
partnering loudspeaker's impedance varies with frequency
will be quite small. This can be seen in fig.1, which shows
the MC1201's frequency response assessed from the 4 ohm tap.
As expected, the variation with our simulated loudspeaker
load was less from the 2 ohm tap, greater (±0.25dB) from
the 8 ohm tap (neither shown).
Fig.1 McIntosh MC1201, 4 ohm tap, frequency response
at (from top to bottom at 2kHz): 2.83V into dummy loudspeaker
load, 1W into 8 ohms, 2W into 4 ohms, and 4W into 2 ohms (0.5dB/vertical
div.).
Even though it uses an output transformer, the
McIntosh's reproduction of a small-signal 1kHz squarewave (fig.2)
was perfect, with no leading-edge ringing and a negligible
downward slope to the waveform tops and bottoms. The 10kHz
waveform (fig.3) was also superb, with just a slight increase
in the leading-edge risetime associated with the ultrasonic
rolloff seen in fig.1.
Fig.2 McIntosh MC1201, small-signal 1kHz squarewave
into 8 ohms.
Fig.3 McIntosh MC1201, small-signal 10kHz squarewave
into 8 ohms.
In general, the MC1201's THD level was very low,
provided the output transformer tap was approximately matched
to the load. But as can be seen from fig.4, when the load is
significantly below the tap rating, there is an increase in
distortion, particularly at high frequencies (though to what
is still a low level).
Fig.4 McIntosh MC1201, 8 ohm tap, THD+noise
(%) vs frequency at (from top to bottom at 4kHz):
2.83V into simulated loudspeaker load, 4W into 2 ohms, 2W
into 4 ohms, and 1W into 8 ohms.
|
Note the rise in distortion in the mid-treble
with our simulated speaker load, which suggests that the big
McIntosh is uncomfortable with loads possessing moderately high
phase angles. (Fig.4, taken from the 8 ohm tap, is the worst-case
example.) However, this may well be of academic interest, given
the amplifier's enormous power reserve and the fact that the
distortion content is almost entirely third-harmonic (figs.5
and 6). Note, by the way, the enormous power levels at which
these two graphs were taken; this was necessary to raise the
harmonic distortion out of the amplifier's very low noise floor.
Even though the third harmonic is well-defined in fig.5, its
absolute level was just 0.0045%! Intermodulation distortion (fig.7)
was also astonishingly low, even at the 800W level at which this
graph was plotted.
Fig.5 McIntosh MC1201, 8 ohm tap, 1kHz waveform
at 455W into 8 ohms (top), distortion and noise waveform with
fundamental notched out (bottom, not to scale).
Fig.6 McIntosh MC1201, 8 ohm tap, spectrum of
50Hz sinewave, DC-1kHz, at 805W into 8 ohms (linear frequency
scale).
Fig.7 McIntosh MC1201, 8 ohm tap, HF intermodulation
spectrum, DC-24kHz, 19+20kHz at 805W into 4 ohms (linear
frequency scale).
|
Figs.8, 9, and 10 show the monster McIntosh's
THD+noise percentage plotted against output power for the 8,
4, and 2 ohm taps, respectively. (The discontinuities in the
curves are due, I imagine, to the Power Guard circuit.) Again
it can be seen that the MC1201 performs best when the load is
approximately the same as the Autoformer tap, in which case the
McIntosh easily exceeds its specified output power (footnote
1).
Fig.8 McIntosh MC1201, 8 ohm tap, distortion (%) vs continuous
output power into (from bottom to top at 10W): 8 ohms, 4 ohms,
and 2 ohms.
Fig.9 McIntosh MC1201, 4 ohm tap, distortion (%) vs continuous
output power into (from bottom to top at 10W): 8 ohms, 4 ohms,
and 2 ohms.
Fig.10 McIntosh MC1201, 2 ohm tap, distortion
(%) vs continuous output power into (from bottom to
top at 10W): 8 ohms, 4 ohms, and 2 ohms.
From the 8 ohm tap, for example, more than
1500W are available into 8 ohms, with well over 2kW delivered
into 4 ohms at the usual 1% THD clipping point. But "only" 700W
can be delivered into 2 ohms from this tap. The power level
indicated on the giant meter, by the way, was correct when
the output tap matched the load.
I couldn't perform my usual pulse testing
with the MC1201; its fully differential output is incompatible
with the single-ended Miller Amplifier Profiler. However,
given the humongous gobs of low-distortion power it can deliver,
McIntosh's MC1201 should be capable of driving all real-world
loudspeakers to very high levels with music program (rather
than continuous tones) without breaking a sweat.—John
Atkinson
Footnote 1: The premature truncation of the
2 ohm trace in fig.9 is due to the MC1201 shutting itself down
due to thermal overload at that point.
|
Sidebar 4: Manufacturer's Comment
Editor: The following bullets are comments
on the technical section of the review, starting at the beginning
of the "Measurements" section.
• The output stage is listed as class-B.
It is actually a class-A/B output stage.
• A comment about the 40-minute operation
at 1/3 power: This is done to keep the top cover of the amplifier
from exceeding 65 degrees C, which is a requirement for CE
certification. The unit is designed using parts that are
safely operated at 80 degrees C and higher. Allowing the
unit to shut down at 65 degrees C is extending the life of
the product. The only music material that is really available
today that is compressed enough to represent 1/3 power would
perhaps be an FM radio station (if you could imagine listening
to 400W continuous). It is reported that the amplifier needed
to be reset when this occurred—the reset is automatic.
Once the amplifier overheats, it mutes the input; after it
cools down, it then unmutes automatically. There is no reset
required by the user.
• The comment about the Grateful
Dead using McIntosh amps: These amps were the MC2300s, which
were forced-air-cooled. Physically they were the same size
as the MC1201, but with a total output of only 600W.
• In reference to figs.8, 9, and
10: I would like to question the consistency in the 2 ohm
load measurements in these graphs—especially fig.10,
where the impedance is matched to the 2 ohm tap. Without
knowing the exact test conditions or type of load that was
used, in my experience in measuring the 2 ohm tap, the connection
of the load can be extremely critical—especially in
its mechanical integrity. I have seen this type of irregularity
on the bench here when the connection is lacking in mechanical
integrity. Each of the graphs seemed to show a consistent
distortion response, except for the 2 ohm, which would lead
me to believe that there is something not consistent with
the 2 ohm test setup.
Here at the factory, each amplifier tap
is checked, loaded with its respective impedance on the production
line, and has to pass at 0.005% THD—as did the amplifier
that was reviewed. This test is done from 20Hz to 20kHz at
1200W and at 12W.—Charlie Randall, McIntosh Laboratory
|
|