 |
| |
 |
| |
| McIntosh Labs MC2000 power amplifier |
| |
| By Jonathan Scull, March 2000 |
| |
I
wasn't raised a McIntosh lad. My dad used Fisher, Bogen, Leak,
and Ampex tubed electronicsand, at one time, even home-built
speakersto keep the house filled with a steady, enriching
flow of Mozart. He never owned a Mac component, and, when going
upmarket, reached for B&O, alas. So while I knew that many
audiophiles hold tubed McIntosh gearespecially the early
designsin very high regard, I was somehow never bitten
or smitten. But let's face itfor lo these many years, McIntosh
has been for many the name in quality American audio. Take my
friend Dan, to whom I've referred several times in the pages
of Stereophile. He runs a tubed Conrad-Johnson 9 preamplifier,
but wouldn't dream of giving up his 270Wpc solid-state McIntosh
MC7270. He's goldurn proud of it!
The McIntosh MC2000
raised a mighty splash when it cannonballed into Sam Tellig's
wading pool. In ST's detailed musings on this gold-plated
hunk o' stereo amp in the November '99 Stereophile, you'll
learn that the MC2000 was designed by Sidney Corderman, McIntosh
co-founder and designer of the legendary MC275. Sidney was
coaxed out of retirement to commemorate the firm's 50th anniversary
with this design. ST, obviously inspired, did a fine job
of describing the philosophy behind the MC2000, and its build,
special transformers, and circuitry. He also heaped glowing
praise on its sound.
So given the hoopla over this ambitious
engineering effort, a formal review was scheduled. To recap,
the McIntosh MC2000: Dual-mono on a single chassis; 130Wpc
from 2, 4, and 8 ohm taps; gold-plated RCA/XLR inputs and
200-amp binding posts; patented Unity Coupled Circuit with
bifilar-wound output transformers; eight KT88s (or 6550s)
with ceramic tube sockets, gold contacts, and Air-Pipe cooling;
twin regulated DC heater supplies on the input tubes; glass
front panel; stainless-steel Titanium Gold Super Mirror gold-plated
finish; and big blue illuminated power meters!
Big Mac
The MC2000 arrived at our door in two
boxes, and it was obvious which held the amp itself. We unpacked,
grunted, and heaved the massive MC2000 onto a PolyCrystal
amp stand. The smaller box contained the tubes, a tube cage,
a screwdriver, and a bias-adjustment tool. Did I mention
the swanky pair of white gloves? Yeah! I'm Fred Astaire!
It's all beautifully done—a real Cadillac
presentation. The tubes come in a gold-toned box with the
Svetlana KT88s and smaller tubes nestled in individual form-fitting
foam depressions. (I used the KT88s supplied, but you can
run the MC2000 with Svetlana 6550s if you prefer.) A translucent
plastic cover sheet indicates the tube's number chocolate-box
style, making it easy to socket them into the amp. The power
tubes are pretested and need not be adjusted for bias until
you replace one or all. And do use the gloves, there's a
good fellow, to avoid greasy bio-smear on the glass. Top
hat and tails optional.
It's all pretty straightforward. My only
complaint is that the heavy-duty binding posts set vertically
on the rear apron are so close to each other that it was
hard to get a grip. Making the task more arduous, the roll-bar
over this rear area gives "on your knees" new meaning. But
that's a reviewer's problem. If you don't often swap cables,
you'll soon forget your aching knees. For the record, I used
the 4 ohm taps on the 3.3-6 ohm JMlab Utopias, and all Synergistic
Research Designer's Reference cables: Active Shielding interconnects
and speaker cables, and Master Coupler Squared power cords.
The BAT VK-50SE was an instant smash hit with the Mac, and
so remained the reference preamplifier for the review.
Mac attack
The McIntosh MC2000 established its voice
early on in the listening. Let's start with Kruder & Dorfmeister's
The K&D Sessions (Warner/Studio !K7 70732). "Wow!" I
jotted. (I'm so literary.) "The air is incredible! So is
the imaging. A punchy sound, rich in the bass, nicely extended,
though it's a touch distended in the punchbowl of the midbass.
Good transition up into the midrange, and then...WOW!" There
I go again.
"The lush, sweep of the midrange ramps
up to lovely and oh-so-attractive upper mids, sweet but textured,
like a Georgia peach. Set above that, the treble seems to
be slightly shelved back. But it's artfully done, not rolled
off, more like subtle makeup on a beautiful middle-aged babe
who only thinks she needs a little help with her looks." While
the sound was smoky, inviting, and sexy, I prefer a treble
that's slightly more lit-up, a tad more open and flinging
its arms at me. The MC2000's embrace was more gentle and
caressing.
|
| |
Do I sound like I'm complaining? Nosireeee
Bob. Gimme more!
On K&D's "Going Under," the Mac set out
an amazing, hugely palpable and present male vocal replete with
compelling lyrics. The fully formed, 3-D imagery was a pleasure
to experience. Every acoustic element was cushioned in huge draughts
of air limitless in scope. Skittering left and right across the
soundstage of this track is a cymbal-like effect that makes a springy,
silvery latticelike sound as it whips back and forth over the lyrics.
The Mac sprinkled it so far beyond the speaker boundaries I had
to crane my neck to track it! The effect was mesmerizing. It was
like...diamonds, a beautiful twinkling luminescence of sound.
From the same album, Lamb's "Trans Fatty
Acid" is another winner, this time for lustrous female vocals
gorgeously rendered. While a touch soft at the very top, once
again the Mac provided an immersive, airy 3-D soundstage projected
way out of the Utopias: far back behind, around, and especially
forward, and almost totally surrounding me as I sat in the
Ribbon Chair! Man, there's just something special about tubes:
that sense of air that's so nurturing to the high-end experience.
Although I've logged fewer hours with the KT88 than with other
power tubes, I can hear what all the fuss is aboutat
least as circuited here by McIntosh.
Switching to another favorite female vocal,
Pat Barber on her latest recording, Companion (Premonition/Blue
Note 22963 2), I found her, per my notes: "Amazing and sexy,
so silky and wondrous and present I wanna go up and hug her!
The air and texture are superb. The sound of the Hammond B-3
is a burnished thing of beauty and lush tonality, existing
so much in space as to defy the fact that it's reproduced sound!"
Whew. I headed back to K&D Sessions,
this time setting up on "Bug Powder Dust" by Bomb the Bass,
which runs a bit like "Cantaloupe" from Us3. Well, I won't
pretend I don't prefer the Linn Klimax Solo 500s for their
superbly tight, bombin' bass on this particular track. Boogie
way down and the MC2000 gets a shade plummy. Interestingly,
even at relatively high levels, the amp's meters flickered
around an indicated 15-20W. While rich and rather full, this
recording's nether regions sounded powerful and encompassing.
The KT88 obviously has more kick'n'grunt
on the bottom than the ubiquitous, venerable, and smaller 6550
tube. I also think its midrange is smoother, and its highs
are certainly less grainy.
Going for the gusto with huge dynamics and
slam, I spun "Afro-Left," from Leftfield's Leftism (Hard Hands/Columbia
CK 67231), and found it surprisingly fulfilling and slammin'
via the Mac. In Chaplinesque manner, the big blue meters in
peak-hold mode heeled, drunkenly, farther and farther to the
right as I cranked the volume, indicating peaks of -5dB on
the lower scalesomething like 80 or 90W at full tilt.
Interestingly, the MC2000 seemed to power out the bass tighter,
and with greater control and authority, as levels increased
past 50W or so. I'd expected it to fall on its face. But no,
the MC2000 sounded more linear as levels increased. I'll be
curious to see how this gold-plated love-puppy measures. McIntosh
isn't afraid of Tom Norton's mighty probe. In fact, they want
the world to see their measurements!
Ahem. Where were we?
The cacophony and pounding, gut-wrenching
slam of "Afro-Left" was amazing to experience, everything holding
its position beautifully. Suck in that gut! A-ten-shun! It
was amazingly tight for a tube amp. In discussing the bass
performance of other components, I've referred before to Depeche
Mode's remix of "Useless" on the K&D Sessions. I've noted
the big bass stroke that gathers itself at around 3:30 to its
rolling-thunder, space-defining crescendo at 3:55. This interesting
acoustical momenta deep, organ-pedal-like fundamental
played on a synthesizeris quite unlike anything else
I've ever experienced, and will define your system's true ability
to handle deep bass. The MC2000 rumbled out a deep and cavernously
spacious final power stroke, altogether real-sounding. I was
astonished.
There seemed no doubt that, as I powered
the MC2000 beyond its rich-sounding idle, it sounded more tight
and linear, if ultimately a touch light in the bass at very
high levels in comparison to the solid-state powerhouses we've
listened to latelyespecially the tight-as-a-drum Linn
Klimax Solo 500s with their 21st-century power supply. Or the
VTL MB-1250 Wotans, for that matter, but let's see...they carry
48 power tubes. Sorta puts things in perspective. The Mac was
roughly equivalent in the bass, I'd say, to the AudioPrism
Mana Reference I reviewed in September '99 (footnote 1).
Footnote 1: Now slightly reworked and available
as the Red Rose Music Model One. Yes, Mark Levinson now owns AudioPrism,
and he's selling tube amps!
|
| |
| But I'm a Libra, and for me, life is all about
balance. If the MC2000's wasn't absolutely the tightest bass
I've ever heard, I can live with it. Take the vibes on disc 1,
track 9 of K&D. The MC2000 laid them out airy, shimmering,
and seductive, the female vocal floating over the powerful, swaying
beat, the ultra-lush midband squeezed out of the tube for the
listener. The bass seemed to curl around her like a vine. Energy
and drive were excellent, and, even at impressive volume levels,
the MC2000 cruised along at only about 25W.
The amplifier also excelled at tying all
elements of a performance together into a very organic and
logical whole. In fact, "Rent Party," from "The
Timekeepers": Count Basie Meets Oscar Peterson (CD,
JVCXR-0206-2; LP, Pablo 2310-896), shows just what the MC2000
is all about. I found myself instantly deep in the music,
enjoying the familiar and elegant musical transitions as
these two old pros handed off the musical line to one another
so gracefully. Around the four-minute mark, the Count leads
with a flourish, countered with an exclamation by Oscar;
the Count's foot taps the beat, then Oscar tickles the keys
a bit more as the Count hums away. Then ensues the single
most wonderful musical conversation I've ever heard. Perfectly
timed, perfectly meshed, they're in each other's heads.
Via the MC2000, the top-to-bottom power
delivery and the rainbow of tonal color were intoxicating.
The differences in miking I've noted with other amplifiers
were perfectly laid out, the acoustically charged air a wonder.
At 5:20 the bass and drums come in, and right there you'll
know why you've just dropped 15 big ones on this amp. It's
the oh-my-gawd-it's-so-gorgeous-I'm-gonna-die effect.
Listening to Mischa Maisky on Cellissimo
(Deutsche Grammophon 439 863-2), I mused: "How do you
get more expressive than this?" It wasn't entirely a
rhetorical question. While I wouldn't accuse the Mac of sounding
as fabulously transparent as the Klimaxes, it always poured
a wealth of detail through the Utopiasnot to mention
the air and sense of place. I heard Maisky's breathing quite
clearly. His bowing had a wonderful rosin-on-string texture
as it swished along "behind" the sound. It put
me fair and square before him in a small, relatively "wet"-sounding
space. The midrange was simply to die for. The organic quality
of performer and sound seemed enhanced by the big Mac.
The little intake of breath before the
first words in Léo Ferré's "La vie d'artiste" on
Avec le temps (Barclay 841 919-2) spoke volumes about the
nuance and detail this amplifier is capable of delivering.
Notes: "Just that little moment establishes his presence
in the soundfield. Just the right chest and texture in his
voice. It's so romantic." Even if you don't speak a
lick of French, you'll feel the meaning and emotion of Ferr;ae's
songs. The slightly hot edge on the top end of this CD was
faithfully reproduced, so I can say that the Mac was a Thoroughly
Modern Millie, not euphonic or warmed up in any way. In fact,
the MC2000's nature was shaded more toward neutral than warm.
A quick flick of the outermost pair of ASC Studio Trapsone
on either side of the outside edge of the Utopiasto
expose a touch more absorbent surface to the drivers did
the trick. Near the end of the piece, Ferré curls
his lipsyou can almost see itand grumbles, "Je
m'en fiche" ("I don't give a damn..."), then
pounds the keyboard, after which the stunning harmonics slowly
fade to black. It's a huge moment. The MC2000 manifested
very little compression, even with the meters heeled over
at 100W as Ferré attacked the keyboard.
Listening to this great leftist French
star perform in our home, I realized that this particular
recording, of which I'm so fond, perfectly speaks to the
very essence of the MC2000. The amp itself is a star of stage
and screen: vivid, round, airy, sexy, powerful, and palpablea
little bit of Hollywood. Okay, it was the merest bit fat
in the midbass, but it sounded very powerful, with a midrange
that left me panting for more, and highs that didn't spoil
the perfect union of performance and joy.
So J-10, how do you really feel?
Under the Golden Arches
Here's the deal: The MC2000 is being
manufactured in a limited edition. McIntosh has already completed
one production run; Larry Fish, vice president of product
planning, says it's completely sold out. The next run will
be completed by the end of McIntosh's fiscal year: March
31, 2000. And that will be that.
But, Fish explained, "There's some flexibility
in the actual numbers produced through that date." So by
the time you're digesting this review, the MC2000 will be
out there in plentiful numbers for those with a discerning
Taste for the Gorgeous and the bucks to back it up. If you're
one of these fortunate souls, don't let the opportunity to
audition it pass you by. It's a classic.
|
| |
Sidebar 1: Specifications
Description: Tubed stereo power amplifier.
Tube complement: eight KT88 or 6550, four 12AX7A, two 12AT7.
Inputs: RCA/XLR with mode switch.
Output meters: left/right channels calibrated in W and dB, mode switch
for peak hold and lights.
Power output: 130Wpc (21.1dBW) into 8, 4, or 2 ohms, 20Hz-20kHz.
Frequency response at 1W output: 20Hz-20kHz, -0.25dB; 10Hz-100kHz, -3dB.
Harmonic distortion at any power level: 0.5%, 250mW to rated power per
channel, 20Hz-20kHz.
Maximum intermodulation distortion: 0.5%, if instantaneous peak power
output doesn't exceed twice the output rating per channel, both driven,
20Hz-20kHz.
A-weighted hum & noise: 100dB below rated output.
Damping factor: greater than 18.
Input impedance: 20k ohms single-ended, 40k ohms balanced.
Input sensitivity (switchable): 2.5V for rated output, 1.2V for rated
output (1V for 100W output).
Dimensions: 173/4" W by 11" H by 183/4" D. Weight: 135
lbs net.
Serial number of unit reviewed: SAC004.
Price: $15,000.
Approximate number of dealers: 260 domestic; 400 foreign.
Manufacturer: McIntosh Labs, 2 Chambers Street, Binghamton, NY 13903.
Tel: (607) 723-3512. Fax: (607) 724-0549. Web: http://www.mcintoshlabs.com/ |
| |
| Sidebar 2: Associated Equipment
Analog source: SpJ tonearm, La Luce turntable.
Cartridges: Koetsu Rosewood Signature Platinum, Forsell Air Force One,
van den Hul Grasshopper IV Gold, Clearaudio Insider.
Digital source: dCS 972 D/D converter, dCS Elgar D/A converter, both
running at 24-bit/192kHz, Burmester 969 and Forsell Air Reference CD
transports.
Preamplifiers: BAT VK-50SE/VK-P-10, Mark Levinson No.32 Reference.
Power amplifiers: Linn Klimax Solo 500s, Forsell Statement, Accuphase
M-2000.
Loudspeakers: JMlab Utopias.
Cables: Interconnects: Synergistic Designer's Reference Active Shielding.
Speaker cables: Synergistic Designer's Reference.
Power cords: Synergistic Designer's Reference Master Couplers Squared,
Electra Glide Fatboy Gold.
Digital datalinks: XLO The Limited AES/EBU.
Accessories: ASC Studio Traps; Argent RoomLenses; API Power Wedge Ultra
116, Ultra Enhancers; Accuphase P-1200 Clean Power Supply; PolyCrystal
amp stand, equipment racks, cones, cable towers; Signal Guard platforms;
Black Diamond Racing shelves, cones; Nordost Pulsar Points; Bright
Star Air Mass/Big Rock combo.Jonathan Scull
|
| |
Sidebar 3: Measurements
Unless otherwise noted, the measurements
given are for balanced operation. Also, unless noted otherwise,
8 ohm measurements were made from the 8 ohm output terminal,
4 ohm measurements from the 4 ohm terminal, and 2 ohm measurements
from the 2 ohm terminal.
Due to a mix-up in returning the MC2000's
tubes to their storage box after the photo shoot for this
issue's coverwhich preceded the taking of these measurementsit's
possible that one or more tubes were not correctly placed
in their specified locations during this testing. In theory,
at least, this would affect the measurements. However, the
bias was checked for the right channel and was spot-on. The
left-channel bias could not be checked because the head of
one of the screws holding the bias cover in place stripped
when we attempted to loosen it. Nevertheless, both channels
measured nearly the same, though with slightly higher distortion
in the left channel. Unless noted otherwise, measurements
performed on one channel only were taken from the left channelour
standard practice.
After a one-hour pretest, the MC2000 was
typically hot for a tube amplifier. Its input impedance measured
19.8k ohms single-ended (unbalanced) and 42.6k ohms balanced.
Single-ended voltage gain into 8 ohms was 28.5dB; balanced
was 23.1dB. The output impedance measured a maximum of 0.4
ohmquite high in comparison with solid-state amplifiers
but admirably low for a tube amp.
DC offset measured a maximum of 6.1mV in
the left channel, 11.1mV in the right. (The measured offset
varied considerably, due to the presence of infrasonic noise,
but the values above were the maximum noted. The signal/noise
ratio (ref. 1W into 8 ohms) measured 79.5dB over a 22Hz-22kHz
bandwidth, 73dB from 10Hz to 500kHz, and 86dB A-weighted.
The corresponding single-ended values were 79.2dB, 73dB,
and 88.5dB, respectively. The MC2000 is noninverting in single-ended
mode, and pin 3 is positive in balanced operation. (Pin-2
positive is more common in the US, but pin-3 positive is
typical in Japan, where I suspect most MC2000s will be sold.)
Fig.1 shows the MC2000's balanced frequency
response. (The unbalanced response is essentially identical.)
Note that the response into a simulated load is relatively
flat for a tube amplifier: approximately ±0.25dB over the
audible range. The 10kHz squarewave response in fig.2 is
very good, with only a slight rounding of the leading edge,
and a small amount of ripple nearly invisible in the plot
shown. (It's more visible when viewed directly on an analog
oscilloscope, but still very hard to spot.) The 1kHz squarewave,
not shown, is nearly textbook-perfect.

Fig.1 McIntosh MC2000, balanced, frequency
response at (from top to bottom at 6kHz): 2W into 4 ohms,
1W into 8 ohms, and 2.828V into simulated loudspeaker load,
(0.5dB/vertical div.).

Fig.2 McIntosh MC2000, small-signal 10kHz
squarewave into 8 ohms.
Channel separation (fig.3) is very respectable:
better in the R-L direction, particularly at higher frequencies,
but, even in the worst case, better than 65dBa figure
unlikely to result in any audible compromise in performance.

Fig.3 McIntosh MC2000, channel separation:
L-R (top) and R-L (10dB/vertical div.).
|
| |
The THD+noise percentage vs frequency
results are plotted in figs.4 and 5. The amplifier is obviously
very linear, other than at very low frequencies (though the
fact that the right channel is better than the left in this
respect might indicate a bias problem). Fig.5 shows a comparison
of the balanced and unbalanced measurements, which are quite
similar. The McIntosh's distortion waveform at 2W into 4 ohms
(fig.6) indicates the presence of second and third harmonics
and some higher-order components, as well as noise.

Fig.4
McIntosh MC2000, balanced, THD+noise (%) vs frequency
at (from top to bottom at 4kHz): 2.83V into simulated loudspeaker
load; 4W into 2 ohms; 2W into 4 ohms; and 1W into 8 ohms.
Fig.5
McIntosh MC2000, THD+noise (%) vs frequency at (from
top to bottom at 6kHz): 2W into 4 ohms, unbalanced; 1W into
8 ohms, unbalanced; 1W into 8 ohms, balanced; and 2W into 4
ohms, balanced.
Fig.6
McIntosh MC2000, 1kHz waveform at 2W into 4 ohms (top), distortion
and noise waveform with fundamental notched out (bottom, not
to scale).
A
spectrum of the MC2000's output while it drives a 50Hz
tone at 87W into 4 ohms (two-thirds rated power) is shown
in fig.7. This is a fairly unimpressive result, though
the highest-level component, the second harmonic at 100Hz,
is still a relatively low 0.25% (-52.7dB). The amplifier
is more linear at higher frequencies. Fig.8 shows the IM
distortion resulting from a combined 19+20kHz signal at
83.5W into 4 ohms. Again, the maximum distortion is approximately
0.13% (-58dB) at 1kHz. At the same power into 8 ohms, the
IM distortion is only marginally lower (not shown).
Fig.7
McIntosh MC2000, spectrum of 50Hz sinewave, DC-1kHz, at 87W
into 4 ohms, 4 ohm tap (linear frequency scale).
Fig.8
McIntosh MC2000, HF intermodulation spectrum, DC-22kHz, 19+20kHz
at 83.5W into 4 ohms, 4 ohm tap (linear frequency scale).
|
| |
The 1kHz, THD+noise percentage vs continuous
output power curves are shown in fig.9. The output is essentially
the same at all load impedances, provided the matching output
tap is used. The MC2000's discrete clipping levels at 1% THD+noise
are shown in Table 1.
Fig.9 McIntosh MC2000, distortion (%)
vs continuous output power into (from bottom to top at 2kHz)
4 ohms, 8 ohms, and 2 ohms (matched impedance taps).
Table 1 McIntosh MC2000 Clipping(1% THD+noise
at 1kHz)
| |
Both Channels
Driven |
One Channel Driven |
| |
W (dBW) |
W (dBW) |
Load
ohms |
(L) |
(R) |
(L) |
| 8 |
162 (22.1) |
164.3 (22.16) |
172.2 (22.36) |
| (line) |
114V |
115V |
116V |
| 4 |
165.5 (19.19) |
164.9 (19.17) |
176.8 (19.47) |
| (line) |
114V |
114V |
115V |
| 2 |
|
|
164.4 (16.16) |
| (line) |
|
|
116V |
Using the Miller Audio Research Amplifier
Profiler to examine the McIntosh's power capabilities using
a low-duty-cycle 1kHz toneburst with one channel driven,
John Atkinson found it be a powerhouse. Matching the tap
to the load gave around 200W at 1% THD+N. But almost the
same power was available into lower impedances. Fig.10, for
example, shows that while the 4 ohm tap will deliver 139W
into 8 ohms and 205W into 4 ohms, it will still output 199W
into 2 ohms and even 107W into 1 ohm, the latter equivalent
to an RMS output current of 10.35A! If you're looking for
a tube amplifier to drive your old Apogee ribbons, the McIntosh
from its 4 ohm or 2 ohm taps will be the perfect choice.

Fig.10 McIntosh MC2000, distortion (%)
vs 1kHz burst output power into 8 ohms (black trace), 4 ohms
(red), 2 ohms (blue), and 1 ohm (green).
While not remarkable, the MC2000's test-bench
results are more than respectable for a modern tube amplifier,
and certainly better than most of the breed, particularly regarding
output current capability.Thomas J. Norton
|
|